Upon arriving on the show, the Hunger Games star reminded Jimmy that she had a bone to pick with him. Apparently, he’d left her high-and-dry, ten jello shots deep at a party, after they’d made a plan to dance with the American Idol judge — but she turned down the offer!
“You made me look like a freak in front of J.Lo!” Jennifer jokingly yelled at the late night host. “Do you know what that feels like!”
Luckily, it seems the duo were able to squash the beef — after Jimmy told his side of the story, they got into some impromptu improv while joking about the incident. Check out the video above to hear the full story!