It certainly didn’t take Andi Dorfman long to move on from her breakup from Josh Murray! Although the reality star was emotional and in tears while discussing the split with Chris Harrison earlier this month, Star has exclusively learned that she’s secretly been spending romantic evenings with her Bachelorette runner-up, Nick Viall!
On the Feb. 15 Bachelor special, the brunette beauty was crying over her breakup, even though she and Josh appeared to be the picture of happiness at The Bachelor Season 19 premiere just weeks before. Through her tears, Andi admitted that, after the premiere, she and Josh had decided to end their engagement, calling it “the biggest failure of my life.”
But she’d seemed to be anything but broken up just two days earlier, when she and Nick were all over each other, drinking and dancing at the Newport Bar & Grill in Chicago. “She seemed very into Nick,” a witness reports. “She had her head on his shoulder, she was hugging him and whispering in his ear. At one point, he had his hand in her lap and then Andi got up and was dancing on the bar.”
In one of The Bachelorette’s most controversial episodes last July, Andi was confronted by the man who finished second on her season of the show. “If you weren’t in love with me, I’m not sure…why you made love with me,” Nick told her. At the time, Andi called the comment “tasteless” and “below the belt,” but she’s clearly figured out a way to put his words behind her now!
To check out an exclusive photo of Andi and Nick together, pick up the latest issue of Star, on newsstands now!