Sources told Shuter’s Naughty But Nice Substack on Monday, October 5, that that Lively, 39, fears she has been replaced in Swift’s inner circle as the singer, 36, continues to publicly show her support for Johnson — a situation that has become “torture” for her.
“Blake was devastated watching it,” a source told Shuter of Swift’s surprise appearance during Johnson’s Saturday Night Livemonologue on October 3. “Taylor wasn’t just supporting Dakota privately. She walked onto that stage and showed millions of people how close they are. Blake couldn’t help wondering: Does Taylor know exactly how much this will hurt me?”
Swift and Johnson’s friendship is not new. The Veritystar, 37, recently confirmed that she and Swift have “been friends for a really long time” and are “very close.”
Casey Flanigan/imageSPACE / MEGA
However, the longtime pals have been particularly more visible together after Johnson starred in Swift’s “Patient Zero” music video, which premiered at the MTV Music Video Awards on Sunday, September 27. Swift subsequently shared behind-the-scenes moments from the shoot on Instagram on Monday, September 28, and recalled “giggling” with Johnson while “twinning for an entire shoot” was a “truly delightful experience.”
Shuter’s sources claim Lively and Johnson, meanwhile, were never close despite both being part of Swift’s circle.
“They tolerated each other for Taylor,” an insider claimed of the actresses. “There was always tension. That’s why seeing Dakota apparently take Blake’s place feels particularly brutal.”
Photo credit: Daniele Cifalà / MEGA
However, another source stressed that Swift’s public friendship with Johnson may have nothing to do with Lively.
“Maybe Taylor isn’t sending Blake any message at all,” the insider told Shuter. “Maybe she simply loves Dakota. Blake has to accept that Taylor’s life no longer revolves around their friendship.”
Swift and Lively were close friends for more than a decade, but their relationship reportedly soured after the singer was pulled into Lively’s bitter legal battle with her It Ends With Us costar and director Justin Baldoni. Swift was referenced in the dispute and later subpoenaed — though the subpoena was ultimately withdrawn in May 2025 — amid claims about her involvement in a meeting concerning the film.
According to Shuter’s source, it is Swift — who is the godmother of the Gossip Girl alum’s children with husband Ryan Reynolds — seemingly moving on that Lively is finding particularly difficult.
“Blake could cope with Taylor being furious,” the source claimed. “What she can’t cope with is Taylor being completely fine without her.”