Nikki Glaser Admitted Her Boyfriend Isn’t Into Her ‘Weird Fetish’ of Hooking Up With Others

Nikki Glaser may like it when her boyfriend steps out of their relationship, but according to her, he doesn’t want her to do the same.

A clip recently resurfaced on X of the comedian, 41 — who has dated Chris Convy on and off since 2013, per People — appearing on Gwyneth Paltrow‘s the goop podcast in March 2025, where she discussed her fetish.

“If I’m in a monogamous relationship, I might have that flutter with someone and like indulge in it, but it can’t go beyond that,” the former FBoy Island host stated, to which Paltrow, 53, questioned, “Why can’t it go beyond that for you?”

“He’s not into that, and like would be a breach for him, so it’s not like a two-way street, which I think is fair because … he doesn’t even want this like my weird fetish,” Glaser explained. “The strange thing is he’s like ‘I don’t need anyone else or crave anyone else, I’ll do it if it turns you on.'”

The Dancing with the Stars alum noted she’s “reluctant” to discuss this topic because, while men think it’s what they want, she feels most “want to be kept.”

Earlier in the podcast, Glaser revealed, “For every person I’ve ever been with, it has always been like a part of foreplay for me to hear about other women, like the almost the courtship process, I like the ‘will they, won’t they,’ like how did you know, like I’m really horny for that.”

“That’s a part that I struggle with of being in a relationship with someone forever that I’m never going to have that again,” she confessed.

As Star previously reported, the actress made headlines in April when she appeared on Call Her Daddy and declared, “In a relationship, I don’t really care if my boyfriend were to hook up.”

However, Glaser seemed to regret her candor. When she appeared on the On with Kara Swisher podcast later that month, she shared, “It was just really embarrassing because I was like that was just one little thing I talked about, like, ‘Oh, I’m kind of turned on by this idea of it.'”

“Everyone I knew had seen that day I went in to do some voice-over work, and people on the Zoom in the voice-over were like, ‘Wow, a lot of headlines about you today,'” Glaser continued. “I’m like that is so humiliating that they know this.”

“I just have to pay more attention now to the stuff I say,” she added.